Thursday, May 17

Beam Me Up, Hockey

Alberta’s drab downtowns should take a tip from America’s sporty urbanization schemes

Subscribe Print this Post Bookmark and Share

By Natasha Mekhail

Falcon

If, in 2,000 years, archeologists study the ruins of our coliseums like those of ancient Greece, what will they say? That peasants sat high up, so their body paint (and nosebleeds) wouldn’t distract the barbaric stick-and-ice players below? That the upper classes reclined in private suites, sipping an elixir of spirits and tomato-clam? That, to reach the coliseum, spectators journeyed for up to an hour by private automobile?

The last part is no joke. It was the subject of a recent mini-conference in Edmonton on the feasibility of a downtown arena for the city. American urban affairs prof Mark Rosentraub, an expert witness, said successful cities (i.e., places where downtown isn’t deserted at 6 p.m.) are putting their stadiums smack in the core. This encourages public transport and pedestrian traffic. It allows an entertainment district of shops, restaurants, bars and arts venues to flourish. Rosentraub, a short-timeline archeologist of sorts, called the old-school arena on the outskirts of town “a spaceship that landed in a sea of parking.” Without big changes, Alberta will go down in history as home to some real motherships.

 

Pengrowth   Pengrowth Saddledome, Calgary
Spaceship rating: Millennium Falcon
 

FalconOne of the world’s largest inverted hyperbolic paraboloid concrete shells, the Saddledome holds a distinct place in the Calgary skyline. But there’s no avoiding the hyperbolic traffic bottleneck after a game.

Opened: 1983
From downtown:
2.3 km
Parking:
3,900 stalls
Compare with:
Los Angeles. Rosentraub calls pre-Staples Center downtown L.A. “a place you went to commit a crime or be the victim of a crime.” But the larger-than-life Staples Center, bathed in light, became a tourist draw, allowing non-offenders to take back the streets.  

 

Centrium   Enmax Centrium, Red Deer
Spaceship rating: Starship Enterprise
 

FalconThe home of the Western Hockey League’s Red Deer Rebels plays up its central location for the two million people living within 150 klicks. But the connected RV park only eliminates the drive for those packing a chemical toilet.

Opened: 1991
From downtown:
4.6 km
Parking:
3,000 stalls
Compare with:
San Diego. The small-market Padres weren’t filling the old ball-park. A bigger lure was needed to draw people from the surrounding counties. The answer was Petco Park, a baseball stadium surrounded by an entertainment district. The San Diego area’s dispersed population suddenly had a list of reasons to head downtown. Attendance soared. 

 

Rexall   Rexall Place, Edmonton
Spaceship rating: Death Star
 

FalconBillionaire Daryl Katz of the Rexall drugstore empire is buying the Oilers and wants to pitch in $100 million for a downtown arena.The city likes the idea but isn’t sure where the remaining $350 million will come from. Could this be Edmonton’s escape pod?

Opened: 1974
From downtown:
6.9 km
Parking:
5,601 stalls
Compare with:
Indianapolis. This otherwise non-descript Midwest city underwent an image overhaul with the arrival of the fancy-pants Lucas Oil Stadium and surrounding centrepiece urban neighbourhood. Today the city’s identity is sports, much better than local author Kurt Vonnegut’s take: “A cemetery with lights.”


Comments are closed.

MOST READ

MOST RECENT

Dangerous Housewives
May 01, 2011 / 10:00 am
Why shopping at the farmer’s market is the most subversive act you’ll do all week
> Read More